When conflict arises, society often assumes that one party must be right and the other wrong. This black-and-white perspective makes it difficult to understand the true role of a mediator—neutrality in mediation. Many people struggle with the idea that a mediator does not take sides but instead validates both perspectives.
The truth is that we all believe we are right from our viewpoint. And in a way, we are. Our experiences shape how we perceive situations, and that perception is real for us. However, if we want others to acknowledge our perspective, we must offer them the same courtesy.
In mediation, the goal is not to determine who is right or wrong but to help both parties understand that multiple perspectives can exist at once.
The Nature of Perspective in Conflict
1. We All Experience Our Own Truth
No two people experience a situation in exactly the same way. Our backgrounds, emotions, and personal histories shape how we interpret events. What feels like an undeniable truth to one person may look entirely different to another.
For example, one employee may feel disrespected in a workplace dispute, while the other may feel they were just being direct. In a family disagreement, one sibling may feel overlooked, while another believes they are independent. These perspectives are both valid, even if they seem contradictory.
2. Extending Understanding to Others
A mediator must ensure both parties feel heard, validated, and respected. When individuals experience this, they become more open to hearing the other person’s perspective, paving the way for real conflict resolution.
If we expect others to acknowledge our perspective, we must also be willing to acknowledge theirs. This does not mean we have to agree, but it does mean we must listen.
One of the most effective ways to illustrate this is through a simple pencil analogy—showing how the same object can look completely different depending on the viewpoint.
The Pencil Analogy: A Simple Yet Powerful Demonstration
Imagine holding a pencil and asking two people to describe its shape.
One person looks at it from the side and sees a rectangle.
The other looks at it straight on from the eraser and sees a circle.
Who is right? They both are.
This simple analogy perfectly illustrates what happens in conflict. Two people may describe the same event in completely different ways, and yet both perspectives are valid based on how they experienced it.
Understanding this is key to neutrality in mediation. A mediator doesn’t tell one party they are right and the other they are wrong. Instead, they help both parties recognize that the other’s experience is just as real and valid as their own.
The Role of Neutrality in Mediation
1. Neutrality Is Not Taking Sides—It’s Seeing the Whole Picture
A common misconception about mediation is that neutrality means indifference. In reality, neutrality is about deep listening, empathy, and fostering understanding. A mediator does not judge who is right or wrong but instead helps both sides see the full picture.
2. Unconditional Positive Regard: A Key Mediation Principle
A fundamental concept in mediation is unconditional positive regard—offering each person a space to express themselves without fear of judgment.
When people feel heard, respected, and validated, they naturally become more open to the other person’s perspective. This shift reduces defensiveness and hostility, making resolution much more achievable.
How This Approach Leads to Resolution
Mutual understanding reduces emotional tension. When people feel understood, they stop fighting to be “right” and start focusing on solutions.
Perspective shifts create room for compromise. When both parties acknowledge each other’s viewpoints, they find common ground more easily.
Lasting resolutions come from empathy, not blame. Agreements built on mutual respect are far more sustainable than those based on forced concessions.
Mediation is not about choosing sides. It is about helping people see that their perspective is one of many—and that true resolution comes from embracing this reality.
Conclusion: A Challenge for Readers
Next time you find yourself in a disagreement, ask yourself:
Am I trying to prove I’m right, or am I trying to understand the other person’s perspective?
If I expect them to see my side, am I willing to see theirs?
Conflict resolution starts with recognizing multiple truths. If you are struggling to navigate a difficult dispute, consider working with a neutral mediator who can help bridge the gap between perspectives.
Looking for expert mediation services? Contact me today to explore how we can help you resolve conflicts with clarity, empathy, and understanding.
Comments